Which cards are worth adding to Scrappy Survivors?

The most common cards in 39 real decks with Dogmeat, Ever Loyal that are not in the precon are Sram, Senior Edificer, Open the Armory, Reyav, Master Smith. For €25 you get 14 of them.

Which cards should you cut from Scrappy Survivors?

Players keep Ian the Reckless, Perception Bobblehead, Squirrel Nest least often: these precon cards appear in only 36–44 % of real decks with Dogmeat, Ever Loyal.

What are the cards in Scrappy Survivors worth?

The 100 cards in the list are worth about €95 together (cheapest paper printings, Cardmarket trend); the most expensive card is Codsworth, Handy Helper at €23.05.

Commander precon · PIP · Mar 8, 2024

Scrappy Survivors

Dogmeat, Ever Loyal

Color identity
Cards: 100
Value of the list: 94.96 €
Data basis: 39 real decks with this commander

Sum of the cheapest paper printings (Cardmarket trend), not the retail price of the product.

In short

Which cards are worth adding to Scrappy Survivors?: The most common cards in 39 real decks with Dogmeat, Ever Loyal that are not in the precon are Sram, Senior Edificer, Open the Armory, Reyav, Master Smith. For €25 you get 14 of them.
Which cards should you cut from Scrappy Survivors?: Players keep Ian the Reckless, Perception Bobblehead, Squirrel Nest least often: these precon cards appear in only 36–44 % of real decks with Dogmeat, Ever Loyal.
What are the cards in Scrappy Survivors worth?: The 100 cards in the list are worth about €95 together (cheapest paper printings, Cardmarket trend); the most expensive card is Codsworth, Handy Helper at €23.05.

Your upgrade budget

The upgrades from above, in order, until the budget is used up. Cards from your collection cost nothing.

14 cards for €9.93

Sram, Senior Edificer 1.04 € Open the Armory 2.34 € Reyav, Master Smith 0.16 € Kutzil, Malamet Exemplar 2.42 € Danitha, New Benalia's Light 0.94 € Akiri, Fearless Voyager 0.37 € Spirit Mantle 0.42 € Danitha Capashen, Paragon 0.24 € Colossus Hammer 0.87 € Unfinished Business 0.21 € Red XIII, Proud Warrior 0.27 € Ethereal Armor 0.24 € Danitha, Benalia's Hope 0.16 € Battlefield Forge 0.25 €

14 cards for €24.85

22 cards for €49.91

36 cards for €99.63

Sram, Senior Edificer 1.04 € Open the Armory 2.34 € Reyav, Master Smith 0.16 € Kutzil, Malamet Exemplar 2.42 € Danitha, New Benalia's Light 0.94 € Bear Umbra 6.29 € Sword of the Animist 3.24 € Kellan, the Fae-Blooded // Birthright Boon 4.97 € Akiri, Fearless Voyager 0.37 € Spirit Mantle 0.42 € Danitha Capashen, Paragon 0.24 € Sigarda's Aid 13.67 € Wyleth, Soul of Steel 3.27 € Colossus Hammer 0.87 € Hammer of Nazahn 4.83 € Blackblade Reforged 1.34 € Shadowspear 18.09 € Unfinished Business 0.21 € Red XIII, Proud Warrior 0.27 € Ancestral Mask 1.61 € Ardenn, Intrepid Archaeologist 3.95 € Forge Anew 3.85 € Ethereal Armor 0.24 € Sheltered by Ghosts 1.57 € Trailblazer's Boots 1.01 € Daybreak Coronet 2.33 € Thran Power Suit 0.63 € Yoshimaru, Ever Faithful 7.99 € Kor Spiritdancer 0.81 € Sythis, Harvest's Hand 2.83 € Nettlecyst 1.23 € Spire Garden 4.79 € Danitha, Benalia's Hope 0.16 € Battlefield Forge 0.25 € With Great Power . . . 0.33 € Shield of the Oversoul 1.07 €

In: the most popular upgrades

Cards that real decks with this commander play most often and that are not in the precon. Sorted by fit with the commander, not just popularity, so Sol Ring does not crowd out everything.

1 Sram, Senior Edificer Legendary Creature — Dwarf Advisor 46 % 1.04 €
2 Open the Armory Sorcery 31 % 2.34 €
3 Reyav, Master Smith Legendary Creature — Dwarf Artificer 28 % 0.16 €
4 Kutzil, Malamet Exemplar Legendary Creature — Cat Warrior 28 % 2.42 €
5 Danitha, New Benalia's Light Legendary Creature — Human Knight 26 % 0.94 €
6 Bear Umbra Enchantment — Aura 26 % 6.29 €
7 Sword of the Animist Legendary Artifact — Equipment 26 % 3.24 €
8 Kellan, the Fae-Blooded // Birthright Boon Legendary Creature — Human Faerie // Sorcery — Adventure 21 % 4.97 €
9 Akiri, Fearless Voyager Legendary Creature — Kor Warrior 21 % 0.37 €
10 Spirit Mantle Enchantment — Aura 21 % 0.42 €
11 Danitha Capashen, Paragon Legendary Creature — Human Knight 21 % 0.24 €
12 Sigarda's Aid Enchantment 21 % 13.67 €
13 Wyleth, Soul of Steel Legendary Creature — Human Warrior 18 % 3.27 €
14 Colossus Hammer Artifact — Equipment 18 % 0.87 €
15 Hammer of Nazahn Legendary Artifact — Equipment 18 % 4.83 €
16 Blackblade Reforged Legendary Artifact — Equipment 18 % 1.34 €
17 Shadowspear Legendary Artifact — Equipment 18 % 18.09 €
18 Unfinished Business Sorcery 15 % 0.21 €
19 Red XIII, Proud Warrior Legendary Creature — Beast Warrior 15 % 0.27 €
20 Ancestral Mask Enchantment — Aura 15 % 1.61 €
21 Ardenn, Intrepid Archaeologist Legendary Creature — Kor Scout 15 % 3.95 €
22 Forge Anew Enchantment 15 % 3.85 €
23 Ethereal Armor Enchantment — Aura 15 % 0.24 €
24 Sheltered by Ghosts Enchantment — Aura 15 % 1.57 €
25 Trailblazer's Boots Artifact — Equipment 15 % 1.01 €
26 Daybreak Coronet Enchantment — Aura 13 % 2.33 €
27 Thran Power Suit Artifact — Equipment 13 % 0.63 €
28 Yoshimaru, Ever Faithful Legendary Creature — Dog 13 % 7.99 €
29 Kor Spiritdancer Creature — Kor Wizard 13 % 0.81 €
30 Super State Legendary Enchantment — Aura 13 % 13.44 €
31 Sythis, Harvest's Hand Legendary Enchantment Creature — Nymph 13 % 2.83 €
32 Nettlecyst Artifact — Equipment 13 % 1.23 €
33 Wooded Foothills Land 18 % 16.74 €
34 Temple Garden Land — Forest Plains 15 % 6.98 €
35 Spire Garden Land 13 % 4.79 €
36 Danitha, Benalia's Hope Legendary Creature — Human Knight 10 % 0.16 €
37 Battlefield Forge Land 13 % 0.25 €
38 With Great Power . . . Enchantment — Aura 10 % 0.33 €
39 Shield of the Oversoul Enchantment — Aura 10 % 1.07 €
40 Unquestioned Authority Enchantment — Aura 10 % 1.02 €

Out: cut candidates

Precon cards that survive least often in real decks with this commander. The lower the rate, the sooner the card goes.

1 Ian the Reckless Legendary Creature — Human Warrior 36 % 0.11 €
2 Perception Bobblehead Artifact — Bobblehead 44 % 1.03 €
3 Squirrel Nest Enchantment — Aura 44 % 0.08 €
4 Agility Bobblehead Artifact — Bobblehead 46 % 1.51 €
5 Veronica, Dissident Scribe Legendary Creature — Human Artificer Rogue 46 % 0.25 €
6 Moira Brown, Guide Author Legendary Creature — Human Citizen 46 % 0.15 €
7 Vault 21: House Gambit Enchantment — Saga 49 % 0.23 €
8 Three Dog, Galaxy News DJ Legendary Creature — Human Bard 49 % 0.16 €
9 Duchess, Wayward Tavernkeep Legendary Creature — Human Citizen 49 % 0.09 €
10 Acquired Mutation Enchantment — Aura 51 % 0.24 €
11 Cait, Cage Brawler Legendary Creature — Human Warrior 51 % 0.22 €
12 Crimson Caravaneer Creature — Human Scout 51 % 0.18 €
13 Temple of the False God Land 51 % 0.07 €
14 Bighorner Rancher Creature — Human Ranger 54 % 0.42 €
15 Mister Gutsy Artifact Creature — Robot Soldier 54 % 0.35 €

Full decklist

Prices: Cardmarket trend prices via Scryfall (cheapest paper printing unless stated otherwise), as of 10/27/2026, updated daily. They can differ from actual buy or sell prices and are not a buying recommendation.

Source of the list: magic.wizards.com · Decklists: MTGJSON (Wizards announcements). Upgrade data: public decklists from Moxfield and Archidekt, updated daily. Prices: Cardmarket trend (cheapest paper printing).

Scrappy Survivors

In short

Your upgrade budget

In: the most popular upgrades

Out: cut candidates

Full decklist

Commander (1)

Creatures (18)

Instants (6)

Sorceries (3)

Artifacts (17)

Enchantments (17)

Lands (38)