Commander precon · PIP · Mar 8, 2024

Mutant Menace

The Wise Mothman The Wise Mothman
Color identity
U B G
Cards
100
Value of the list
111.68 €
Data basis
137 real decks with this commander

Sum of the cheapest paper printings (Cardmarket trend), not the retail price of the product.

In short

Which cards are worth adding to Mutant Menace?
The most common cards in 137 real decks with The Wise Mothman that are not in the precon are Mesmeric Orb, Mindcrank, Ruin Crab. For €25 you get 6 of them.
Which cards should you cut from Mutant Menace?
Players keep Piper Wright, Publick Reporter, Strength Bobblehead, Lumbering Megasloth least often: these precon cards appear in only 9–10 % of real decks with The Wise Mothman.
What are the cards in Mutant Menace worth?
The 100 cards in the list are worth about €112 together (cheapest paper printings, Cardmarket trend); the most expensive card is Guardian Project at €12.67.

Your upgrade budget

The upgrades from above, in order, until the budget is used up. Cards from your collection cost nothing.

6 cards for €9.90

Mindcrank 7.79 € Ruin Crab 1.02 € Syr Konrad, the Grim 0.51 € Evolution Witness 0.19 € Fathom Mage 0.27 € Thrummingbird 0.12 €

6 cards for €24.96

Mesmeric Orb 11.20 € Mindcrank 7.79 € Ruin Crab 1.02 € Syr Konrad, the Grim 0.51 € Ripples of Potential 4.32 € Thrummingbird 0.12 €

15 cards for €49.88

Mesmeric Orb 11.20 € Mindcrank 7.79 € Ruin Crab 1.02 € Syr Konrad, the Grim 0.51 € Ripples of Potential 4.32 € Kami of Whispered Hopes 2.45 € Evolution Witness 0.19 € Bloodchief Ascension 15.14 € Muldrotha, the Gravetide 0.87 € The Water Crystal 2.29 € Assassin's Trophy 1.12 € Evolution Sage 2.09 € Fathom Mage 0.27 € Thrummingbird 0.12 € Hollowmurk Siege 0.50 €

21 cards for €99.78

Mesmeric Orb 11.20 € Mindcrank 7.79 € Ruin Crab 1.02 € Syr Konrad, the Grim 0.51 € Ripples of Potential 4.32 € Kami of Whispered Hopes 2.45 € Evolution Witness 0.19 € Bloodchief Ascension 15.14 € Muldrotha, the Gravetide 0.87 € Watery Grave 9.82 € Breeding Pool 9.71 € The Water Crystal 2.29 € Overgrown Tomb 8.64 € Altar of the Brood 5.81 € Assassin's Trophy 1.12 € Evolution Sage 2.09 € Fathom Mage 0.27 € Danny Pink 14.69 € Thrummingbird 0.12 € Hollowmurk Siege 0.50 € Bojuka Bog 1.23 €

In: the most popular upgrades

Cards that real decks with this commander play most often and that are not in the precon. Sorted by fit with the commander, not just popularity, so Sol Ring does not crowd out everything.

  1. 1 Mesmeric Orb Artifact 74 % 11.20 €
  2. 2 Mindcrank Artifact 74 % 7.79 €
  3. 3 Ruin Crab Creature — Crab 67 % 1.02 €
  4. 4 Syr Konrad, the Grim Legendary Creature — Human Knight 55 % 0.51 €
  5. 5 Ripples of Potential Instant 53 % 4.32 €
  6. 6 Kami of Whispered Hopes Creature — Spirit 50 % 2.45 €
  7. 7 Evolution Witness Creature — Elf Shaman Mutant 50 % 0.19 €
  8. 8 Bloodchief Ascension Enchantment 50 % 15.14 €
  9. 9 Muldrotha, the Gravetide Legendary Creature — Elemental Avatar 49 % 0.87 €
  10. 10 Watery Grave Land — Island Swamp 53 % 9.82 €
  11. 11 Breeding Pool Land — Forest Island 52 % 9.71 €
  12. 12 The Water Crystal Legendary Artifact 46 % 2.29 €
  13. 13 Overgrown Tomb Land — Swamp Forest 47 % 8.64 €
  14. 14 Altar of the Brood Artifact 42 % 5.81 €
  15. 15 Assassin's Trophy Instant 44 % 1.12 €
  16. 16 Evolution Sage Creature — Elf Druid 39 % 2.09 €
  17. 17 Fathom Mage Creature — Human Wizard 37 % 0.27 €
  18. 18 Danny Pink Legendary Creature — Human Soldier Advisor 36 % 14.69 €
  19. 19 Polluted Delta Land 41 % 19.12 €
  20. 20 Thrummingbird Creature — Phyrexian Bird Horror 35 % 0.12 €
  21. 21 Zagoth Triome Land — Swamp Forest Island 36 % 16.78 €
  22. 22 Undergrowth Stadium Land 36 % 4.81 €
  23. 23 Rejuvenating Springs Land 35 % 3.92 €
  24. 24 Hollowmurk Siege Enchantment 32 % 0.50 €
  25. 25 Bojuka Bog Land 36 % 1.23 €
  26. 26 Counterspell Instant 38 % 0.80 €
  27. 27 Incubation Druid Creature — Elf Druid 31 % 1.37 €
  28. 28 Terrasymbiosis Enchantment 31 % 9.94 €
  29. 29 Reanimate Sorcery 33 % 8.13 €
  30. 30 Hedge Shredder Artifact — Vehicle 28 % 1.78 €
  31. 31 Icetill Explorer Creature — Insect Scout 28 % 21.40 €
  32. 32 Verdant Catacombs Land 33 % 23.87 €
  33. 33 Swiftfoot Boots Artifact — Equipment 36 % 0.96 €
  34. 34 Heroic Intervention Instant 33 % 10.37 €
  35. 35 Nature's Lore Sorcery 33 % 2.05 €
  36. 36 Bruvac the Grandiloquent Legendary Creature — Human Advisor 27 % 32.67 €
  37. 37 Drown in the Loch Instant 26 % 0.77 €
  38. 38 Shifting Woodland Land 27 % 5.49 €
  39. 39 Psychic Corrosion Enchantment 26 % 3.10 €
  40. 40 Maddening Cacophony Sorcery 26 % 4.65 €

Out: cut candidates

Precon cards that survive least often in real decks with this commander. The lower the rate, the sooner the card goes.

  1. 1 Piper Wright, Publick Reporter Legendary Creature — Human Detective 9 % 0.27 €
  2. 2 Strength Bobblehead Artifact — Bobblehead 10 % 1.75 €
  3. 3 Lumbering Megasloth Creature — Sloth Mutant 10 % 0.27 €
  4. 4 Biomass Mutation Instant 12 % 0.14 €
  5. 5 Tireless Tracker Creature — Human Scout 13 % 0.22 €
  6. 6 Recon Craft Theta Artifact — Vehicle 14 % 1.35 €
  7. 7 Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet Legendary Creature — Zombie Mutant Advisor 17 % 0.76 €
  8. 8 Young Deathclaws Creature — Lizard Mutant 20 % 0.16 €
  9. 9 Temple of the False God Land 20 % 0.07 €
  10. 10 Watchful Radstag Creature — Elk Mutant 21 % 1.47 €
  11. 11 Harold and Bob, First Numens Legendary Creature — Treefolk Mutant 21 % 0.18 €
  12. 12 Vault 87: Forced Evolution Enchantment — Saga 22 % 0.25 €
  13. 13 Harmonize Sorcery 22 % 0.14 €
  14. 14 Ash Barrens Land 23 % 0.09 €
  15. 15 Lily Bowen, Raging Grandma Legendary Creature — Mutant Warrior 24 % 0.30 €

Full decklist

Commander (1)

Creatures (28)

Instants (7)

Sorceries (7)

Artifacts (10)

Enchantments (8)

Lands (39)

Prices: Cardmarket trend prices via Scryfall (cheapest paper printing unless stated otherwise), as of 10/27/2026, updated daily. They can differ from actual buy or sell prices and are not a buying recommendation.

Source of the list: magic.wizards.com · Decklists: MTGJSON (Wizards announcements). Upgrade data: public decklists from Moxfield and Archidekt, updated daily. Prices: Cardmarket trend (cheapest paper printing).